If the Tribunal was a net-negative in the community and did more damage than good, I'd turn it off immediately. I've done the research and had that discussion before. The Tribunal's positive value far out-weighs the negative, which is why we are doing additional features to improve it.
At some point in the future if the Tribunal becomes a net negative, I'd shut it down. I'm a logical person and I'll always make the call that gives our players better experiences.
In no way am I saying to shut down the Tribunal, don't get me wrong. I just want it fixed is all (not to say your not trying to improve it or fix it). I report just as much as the next guy for certain things, such as stuff that is out of my control (int.Feeding, Or telling the enemy team information vital to the success of the team i'm a part of). Is there any way by chance to get a "click poll" on the client for forum purposes to see the actual Popularity (be it +/-)
of the tribunal?