Originally Posted by RiotKiddington
Based on the The Tribunal Guidelines:
So it is basically controversial?
It concerns me because there was a point where a Riot Employee said that after a certain amount of reports have been made, you will be thrown into the Tribunal. When 1 report was real, but you wouldn't have been placed in the Tribunal, then the 2 fake ones pushed it in there, how should I react?
I mean, should I pardon him because of the fake reports to penalize the people who think everyone they report is going to get punished, or should I Punish him and reward the players that made the fake reports?
I really want to know how you guys would handle it because these types Tribunal cases don't seem like they should be left up to the player base to decide due to the improper reports going around.
I would like to punish the players that decided to abuse the report system... As for the person that only had 1/3 real reports, what kind of punishment would he receive if 2 of the 3 reports were fake? Would he get the same punishment as someone that got 3/3 real reports despite there being fake reports? I mean, he was falsely pushed into the Tribunal early as well...
I guess I would have to vote Pardon on this kind of thing since more than 50% or the reports were false. Would be nice to have everything perfect, but I guess it can't happen unless I worked at Riot heh.