So after being able to review the case since the link is working, game 1 and 2... What was I punished for exactly? Game 3 and 4 are somewhat controversial and I can understand getting punished if the Tribunal is reviewing what you said and did and what you said and did only. But that doesn't make the Tribunal right, because whether it be real life, or in this video game, if someone insults me, or threatens me, or anything of the sort, I'm going to come right back at them, and that goes for the vast majority of people in the world. That's just the way it is. I accept the punishment I was given, but I don't agree with it. If someone is going to be punished, everything that happened in the game, by everyone in the game, that lead to a person saying a few controversial things, which then lead to their punishment, should be taken into context. That makes the most sense and seems the most fair to me. I don't see how anyone can disagree with that.
Game 2 - No idea why that's in there. Unless it happened in pre- or post- game chat, then I can't seem to find what the comment is referencing.
Game 3 - 2 minutes and 30 seconds of going off on your team...that's not controversial at all, it's reportable, and something I would punish for.
Game 4 - Called Gangplank retarded around 19 minutes, and in the end called your whole team "tards". Again, not controversial in the slightest.
If this doesn't amount in a permaban for you (you did say 4 bans already), I would make the following recommendations.
1) Don't say anything, unless it's positive.
2) Don't respond to people being jerks, in-kind. That's what the mute button is for.
If you truly can't hold back at someone being an ass, then you probably won't be able to stop, and will end up with a permaban. It's not just you and one other person throwing insults back and forth, there are another 3 people on the team who have to put up with it. On top of having to read it(if they don't mute), it does absolutely nothing to help the team.
To be upfront, if it happened in a game I was in, I'd report both of you.