Greetings Summoners,

Before you say this is just another QQ thread about someone getting banned, it isn't. I have never been banned, and have been playing the game since the it launched. Heck, I even bought the game because it offered the original heroes. So you could say that I have been playing quite a long time. However recently I decided to start climbing the ranked ladder.

I come to these forums a good bit, but rarely ever post, primarily because these forums remind me of World of Warcraft.

But after reading and participating in the tribunal cases on several different occasions I have to say I think it is the most flawed justice system I have ever seen in my life.

The Tribunnal is not about whats right or wrong as a society, but what whats right or wrong in a single individuals eyes. What I mean by that is some people justify killing other people by whatever means they see fit. That makes it right in their eyes. Though the tribunnal is set up to be ran like a jury, it isn't. Even in court the prosecutor, and defender are allowed to pick / eliminate jurors. This is much more fair.

Instead here is an example: 15 random people decide to participate in the Tribunnal. These 15 people are all nice guys with a family, but more importantly there morals are that of a family man. When they see someone say something like, "quit feeding", or "you are bad" they would report that person. Now here they are judging people based of how they think. The Tribunnal case gets banned because of these 15 people. But what the perp did wasn't that bad.

Or in another case 15 elitest jerks could decide to participate. So they get on there and they all 15 decide "quit feeding", or "you are bad" is tolerable. Then they see the kill death ratio is 0-15. Obviously this person was feeding and not having a bad game. So they vote to Punish this person.

Or you could just have those people who really don't care to read any of it. But participate in it. They just randomly hit pardon, or punish. Without any thought to the process.

So no this system will never work it will punish the innocent, and set free the criminals.

While I know there is no fair system, even in the real world. I think players should have to go through a test or something. A personality test, and if they do not score high enough on this test, then they are not allowed to participate.

You could also stop players from going onto the next case for like 5 minutes. I know personally when I was being part of the tribunnal I took my time, read all of the chat log, looked at the scores, as well as the other cases ( in the event they had one ). Then I made a decision. This generally took about 5 minutes. This would stop the people who are only doing it just to be a-holes, or to get the ip.

I know how hard it must be for riot to manage each and every report that goes into the game, but I do not think letting the player base decide the out come is the way to go.

Thanks.