Originally Posted by Crucefix
I punished this case because I didn't want him in my team and now you unban him.
This guy trolls all the time, the plays poorly on purpose, doesn't care about the team and he throws games really hard. He is a troll that tries to look like a bad player to the tribunal...
There isn't enough evidence supporting that statement. As you said he looks merely like a bad player. We cannot punish him for this reason.
Looks like tribunal does really not work, if they unban people who should be punished...
Interesting, I thought I was overly strict on punishing people, but your even stricter. Most of these things that you picked out in your earlier post are very borderline for most people which is why they would pardon in this situation. The OP is not like most people who are in the Tribunal who spew **** and don't stop. Yea he may have been offensive at times. But he kept it short and moved on after being attacked by others and not overly offensive.
Also you made the assumption that he didn't tell his teammates about weird picks. How do you know he didn't say in pre game chat? It does tend to cause people to show more animosity when things go wrong towards the person but you still can't make that assumption in the first place.
Pretty much the reason he got unbanned is because the only evidence we have of anything is that he is an unskilled player that doesn't always follow the meta, and neither occurrence is bannable.