That is a tricky case. For most of the game in all of the games the player was fine. There were really only a handful of bad comments, considering the overall amount of comments which would justify punishment. Cases like this are hard to judge, people who would punish normally skip because they are rating junkies and would rather rule on easy cases that they know will go in there favor which is how these get pardoned. Honestly I'd have pardoned this one too, some trash talk is fine in the game, only when it becomes excessive does it become an issue for me.