Originally Posted by Keonyn

I'm generally more lenient than most (or so I believe), but I've had a number of cases lately where I punished and the end result was a pardon from the Tribunal. I'm not quite sure it's an epidemic though since while 5 of my last 6 were pardons, there is only 1 other pardon total on the rest of the page and only 2 on the page prior. So I don't know, sometimes I felt the system was a little too bias to punish before.

The one that really baffles me though is this recent one:

http://na.leagueoflegends.com/tribunal/case/6151473/

As you can see the Tribunal majority opinion was to punish, and you need only look at the chat log in the games to see why. However, on my list it shows that in spite of the majority decision to punish the user was pardoned, and if you view the case it clearly shows a punishment of none. I mean, you don't even need to scroll down at all on the 1st games chat to see this persons toxic behavior and yet they're pardoned? Simply amazing.

Originally Posted by Enterti

That is actually a common bug check it again in half an hour or so it should switch

Originally Posted by YoshioPeePee

rest assured that player was punished, probably with a perma ban

Originally Posted by Keonyn

That one posted days ago, hasn't switched yet. I really hope it is just a bug because someone getting away with that kind of behavior would be unacceptable.


Ah, hopefully that's the case here. Good to know at least that there's a good chance they weren't pardoned after all. Of my recent cases this one was by far the most deserving of punishment, so you can imagine my surprise when it came back on my list stating "Pardon".

Originally Posted by Lyte

We'll take a look at this. Something looks off.