nice work, but i played this map since release on pbe almost everyday, with good and bad payers. probably more than 1k games in it. i disagree with most of it BUT the thing is, i beleive there is a tier list for every level of play. we cannot make a good one til they make a queue for it. i seen nidalee failing really hard when the level of play was low. trundle is actually incredibly stong sustain/debuffs and bush control i would place him in tier 2, but again no one really plays him and people dodge when they get him.
imo lux and maokay are the god tiwer champs in this map when the elvel of play is high, i ban both in adam matches when i play with proving grounds veterans. it is simply impossible to push vs a lux when her ulti cd is lower than minion wave respawn you need to handicap your team by bying **** load of armor if you are a tank to give the opporunity for your team to fight under enemy towers. since most comps are 3-4 ap. that armor isnt that useful overall. ap mao is god tier because he is so easy to build without waisting stats and his kit is just perfect, **** load of burst, cc and aoe ult with damage reduction. mao is simply a swiss knife. he only lacks dps because you wont build ad on him obviously. and yes you are right about jayce being a more powerful pick since he can carry, but nidalee can win games with her supportish gameplay style. 2 spears and the next fight will feature 2 low hp enemies. and she can still be useful with heals, 60% as buff on your adc, mr and armor debuffs, and insane cleanup with cougar form. you cant really compare both, they are way too different, most people dont compare nid with jayce, they compare nid q with jayce q.
also imo caitlyn is the best adc since she provides bush control for early domination, her ult is better in this map than in sr since epople cannot recall and damage is permanemet unless they use summoners or have sustain. she is so hard to kill and provides utility.
also you should add super godlike tier wherre there will be only 1 champ. black terror talon (pre bc nerf lol) only countered by getting 2 warmogs. rip true damage talon
also cant wait for the proving ground queue XD i hope champ select wont be random or people wil jsut buy the most op 16 champs and queue there gg 100% chance tog et op champ good luck wining if you have 100 champs unlocked. arma queue would be possible only if they make it like this:
-required 50 unlocked champions
-in some special menu, you need to select the 50 champions that you will queue with. so 2% chance of getting each one of them. it will be then fair
ato come back in the main subject. i play you classified tier 4 trundle in draft when enemy have only 1 tank. proceed to ult tank, q the ad then type in chat: where is your tank nao mouahahahhahahahha. then proceed to dunk. dont forget to troll pillar an ulting enemy kat.