Originally Posted by Gunbladefire
Did you read my other post? and besides I think these items would be viable easily for ranged characters as well other than just ryze such as ashe, fortune, and graves.
I did skim over it, and that's why I gave you a warning before writing my own thoughts about your suggestions. You went on the internet and asked for criticism. While there wasn't anything positive I could say, I made sure to be polite about it at least. And the only thing you can say in response to any of my valid criticism--negative, but valid--is that you THINK the item that just gives 650 Mana, 10 MP5 and 5 mana per hit would be viable on Ranged carries.
Your definition of viable and the actual definition set by good players are many leagues apart. A carry is a champion that wants all damage items. If they wanted a damage item that gave mana, they'd grab Manamune/Muramana instead of this PoS, because they'd get more mana, enough regen, and to top it off they'd get a minimum 25-40 AD and that toggle to deal 3% of their mana in damage per hit.
And yet, that item sees almost no play in high ELO. Wanna know why? Because it provides less damage, and really is just an excuse to spam skills. And the only champions who need it are Ezreal (debatable), Urgot and Yorick.
You can try to convince me it's viable, but speaking from years of experience, it's not.