Garen's a broken sword-using champion, that's pretty close.
#jokes

This BotRK is an awesome item. Just REMOVE the ACTIVE. Still a good item. Still gold efficent.

But what do with active? Take an item, give it 80AD, and the 15% total HP as physical + heal active.

What does this do? Well, ADCs buy the new BotRK, since it's about HP shred, AS and minor AD.

Bruisers buy the new item, for AD scaling skills and that big physical nuke.

Much like L's Torment and DFG.

That's a major over nerf. It goes from having about 400 gold of free stats, to... well no free stats. Increase the price by 350 and reduce AD by 5, and nerf the hell out of the active. It probably goes into negative free stats at that point lol...

Don't knee jerk and do big changes. Nerf it a tiny little bit. People only think it's so strong cause they are still building HP...

Each time I test it, it does - but I keep getting reports that it doesn't. Unsure.

Option C... make Armor and MR better and health worse?

So any current BotRK user!

No, that's just option B again.

I'm glad we're going to see some fixes come to the item as it clearly got out of hand. But, I've always been under the impression that it is really hard to continuously auto-attack in a team fight setting. This is why generally Tryndamere, Sion, etc. have issues performing as the game goes on. There's a lot of CC.

The one side effect of BotRK being so prevalent is as an ADC or Bruiser who builds it, you actually got attack speed early on. This in my mind makes the fights more interesting because instead of all-out burst being the main force of fights there's a bit more maneuvering and AAing (for the most part, the active adds to much burst).

How does your team feel about the state of auto-attacking especially as the game moves into more involved fights?

ADC's yeah won't build both BC and LW besides MF, but you had renek's, pants, Lee's, Talon's, Zed's, Kha all doubling the items or back when the flat stacked they'd put 2 on. The build was absolutely dominating on MF, who has since stopped with the nerfs. The ADC itself probably had only around 42% but you have over proliferation of armor shred in a game. Way more then you seen in season 2 and with the new formula it destroyed all the balance you had.

I mean you have an ADC sitting on like 43%+5+innate from champions+ BC. I think this is mainly a problem with how much armor shred is in the game as of right now. A lot of the main champions played all have good armor shred abilities. I think we're facing over saturation more then anything.