Originally Posted by Carados
The problem isn't that people queue dodge to get what champion the want, the problem is that people think they alone should choose whatever champion they want regardless of team composition.
The fact that they are dodging in this case is a symptom of the underlying problem. You're only attempting to fix one symptom, and in doing so, encouraging the rest of the symptoms associated with the problem.
Think about this for about 40 seconds and realize why the suggestion is terrible.
So Carados, this sounds exactly like the type of posts you are making in the PTR Teemo feedback thread.
Something that needs improvement (Teemo, Queue Dodging) has a suggested improvement (by Riot, by myself), and your argument against each is that it "doesn't fix the entire problem".
Whatever happened to taking steps to fix something so that you don't overcompensate?
Should we just give all 3 of Teemo's abilities that do damage scale 1:1? That would make him MORE than viable.
Should we make queue dodging have a 24 hour ban? Then nobody would do it.
Overcompensating is not the issue, and you have failed to explain why THIS idea (allowing pre-select of champions in an effort to significantly reduce dodging on new-champ-weeks and slightly reduce it at other times) puts the system in a WORSE position than it is now. Or, alternately, why putting a system like it into place is counter-productive to the final system that you envision being functional.