Originally Posted by Dead Future
In your professional opinion, would you consider the implementation of "Tribunal Reform Cards" after many players have been permanently banned (some of which having made large changes in their behavior due to the sobering effect of having everything they've ever earned being taken away from them) an oversight of sorts?
I don't mean to put words in your mouth, but would you then consider this to be a price for the "greater good" of the community?
As a member of the "I respect the Summoner's Code and try to be a positive force in the game" club, I am angry when reading this.
I am very, very angry when I read this.
Call me intolerant if you will, but that's how it is. I am really tired of toxic players ruining the game I'm trying to enjoy, time and again. What I want is to get rid of toxic players. I want them OUT OF MY GAME.
I want the Tribunal to hand bans to people who deserve it. I want it to be a community cleaner : I want it to take out the trash, the 1 jerk in 10 people, so the other 9, the decent people who can actually behave correctly in social situations, can enjoy this awesome game.
I couldn't care less about the fate of the guy who gets thrown out.
There were clear rules; the guy didn't respect them; too bad, maybe next time you won't be such a jerkface.
All the rest is icing on the cake. It's nice to be lenient; it's nice to allow people to reform; it's nice to be able to educate people and make them become non-toxic, if not positive; it's nice that there is a team working on this at Riot. I am all for helping people become better, and I really respect the work Lyte and his team are doing here.
But it is all a bonus. They don't have to do this.
I, for one, would be perfectly happy with a very strict, purely eliminatory system, without the possibility of reforming. You broke the rules, you get thrown out, period. You blew your chance. We are 9 better human beings here, please care for us instead of the toxic one.
The Tribunal team does't do this. The Tribunal team is going out of its way to be helpful and allow people to reform and become better people.
And you, Dead Future, and people like you, are pointing out flaws in what they do, insinuating that it's not enough, or not fast enough; that people will be left out, people who could have reformed.
Well, you know what ? Too bad for them.
You have no business accusing the Tribunal team; they are already doing far more than banned people deserve.
I even find it highly suspicious that you are trying to make people who have been convicted of toxicity
, i.e. culprits
, appear like victims
. Maybe you have something on your conscience ?
Yes, this post is aggressive. I am not like this in game. I am a nice guy who's tired of being shat on. Nice guys have the right to get angry when they see obvious BS ; this is why Pendrakills have such success, it's the only time when we actually feel we are getting fair retribution.