Originally Posted by Tempestphile
Rank 5 Reckless swing is 340
Rank 3 Noxian Guillotine is 640 max (+150% AD)
Clearly Olaf can dish out more...
Yes, Darius might be an ulti, but then it resets on kill, so cooldown as an argument point is pointless.
The thing about Olaf is that he doesn't need to wait for targets to get low in order to spam his true damage nuke, he just mashes E whenever its off cooldown on anyone he pleases.
Darius has to wait for stuff to 1) get 5 stacks of his passive and 2) get to low enough health that he can finish them off with it.
Olaf pretty much opens fights with his true damage, and keeps using it throughout the course of a duel.
Like the others said, Olaf will be dishing out more true damage more quickly over the course of a game than Darius can.