Why is everyone alsways so binary on this topic. Revive is good for the health of dominion the problems is in its current state its way too strong. Have you guys just forgotten nerfs are an option?
The binary response is probably due to people who enjoy an established meta vs a not so clear one. Revive gives clear direction as to if your team will work in blind queue (like in draft SR, you get flamed for not getting flash unless top lane, and how people graon when they see a lack of rev in blind queue here).
A not so clear meta results in the need for experimentation in blind queue which I think a lot of people would hate (especially with the amount of A-S tier champ picks, even in high elo blind queue).
So, do you love order, or chaos? (insert binary responses here).