So, going off of what you just said you admitted to being one sided during the judgements and not reading the ENTIRE case, because if you do I think I cursed one time in that game, while I was cursed at several (basically proving my point on this case at least) that the tribunal is broken and leaving the judgement to the players is a terrible idea as 80-85% of the players are too lazy to read the ENTIRE game, or look at the fact that the person in question is carrying and their team is doing terrible, because whenever I carry and my team brings me down and makes me almost lose (I never lose btw.) I get fairly agitated as does the rest of the league of legends community.
What I am saying is:
When it is pretty obvious that person is verbally abusing one or more people, then it is generally not needed to read the chat from everyone, but just the purple chat, which is the accused player's chat.
Besides, even in most cases where "he started it", it is not needed to read other people's chats.
One player is judged by his own behavior, if his behavior is one or more of these
Cassiopeia [All] [00:08:25] press R and get penta's?
Cassiopeia [All] [00:08:27] omg so hard..
Cassiopeia [All] [00:08:33] I cramp up sometimes honestly.
Cassiopeia [All] [00:14:00] surrender@20 please I need to go somewhere soon.
Cassiopeia [All] [00:21:21] jessus you are pathetic..
Cassiopeia [All] [00:21:24] all of you honestly.
Whats wrong with being "one sided" anyway? We are there to vote to punish ONE player, not the whole team.
BTW, where did you get the number that 85-90% players doesn't read the whole chat? It is a very good statistics, if you can prove it as true, that is it.