Originally Posted by Adrian Umbra
Do you play Amumu? Do you play Nautilus? Have you noticed that they're COMPLETELY different champs? Have you noticed that Amumu gets very little natural tankiness? Have you noticed that if Amumu whiffs an ult he has very little to contribute to a fight? And give us some examples of how he "does too much damage," please.
If you really want to make a good argument too, don't resurrect a week old thread to make a complaint like this. It just makes you look unoriginal.
Yes I have played Amumu and I used to play Naut almost exclusively in S2.
They may be different champions, but they both serve similar roles as tanky initiators/disruptors.
Amumu may get very little natural tankiness, but Nautilus has even less, along with much higher cooldowns. As for damage it's not even close, Amumu has much more damage overall, even without his ult.
I've played against quite the number of Amumu's (from AP to full tank) and I think he does too much damage for how tough he can be to kill, and how disruptive he can be, in teamfights.
Even without his high damage he would still be useful imo.
Depth Charge has the capacity
to turn the tides, but it's quite sensitive to context/team compositions.
Curse of the Sad Mummy will
turn the tides, even if it only hits 2 people.
It takes a little too much to counter Amumu imo, at least compared to other tanks.