I'd go with Gangplank. Sure Amumu's will destroy a team (if they stand next to him and get close together anyway), but Plank's can be used to push a tower, defend a tower, cover for escape, stop people from escaping, long range KS/ganking or as DPS in a team battle, and unlike Amumu, you dont need to be near him (and you can't cleanse cannonballs falling on your head, as oppose to cleansing bandgaes and running, in which case you've taken damage and need to fall back- at least till the ult is done).