I did the tribunal for my first time tonight, here is proof that it is broken.

The screenshot shows that 1 person out of everyone reported this person for feeding when their score is clearly positive.

The tribunal is idiotic, that is all.

Edit - Unless im missing, from what I see here, People can report anyone for anything (even if untrue) and others will have a chance to punish them.

You are misunderstanding the wide scale scope of the system. Even if you vote punish on that ticket, your one vote wont send an email to Riot. Even when that email does go to riot, if enough people do click that punish button; Riot reviews the case before a ban is sent out; you clicking punish is just telling riot "I think this person should be punished"

your missing the fact epople will jsut say yes whitout lookign for free ip and riot is an automatic system.

You obviously haven't researched the system, the only thing that is automatic; is warnings. Any actual action against an account that would effect your ability to play the game is reviewed by a Riot employee before hand.

It is widely agreed that the IP system is flawed, I never argued that fact, so I'm not exactly sure how I was "missing it?", but regardless someone being issued IP does not mean that a ban has been issued. It simply means the Tribunal ticket has now been forwarded to Riot for review, as enough summoners have made a similar vote. It the ticket does not have merit, Riot will decline the Punish that people had pushed through.

The system will then automatically record that they had voted improperly on the case. Should it happen on a regular enough basis, the system will catch notice, and eventually (Takes some time due to the amount of reports that DO warrant a punish) their tribunal privileges will be revoked.

Show me one place where Riot states that a 7 day suspension is reviewed by riot before being placed onto an account.

Happy?

Not unless he wins, so probably not.

Rofl

Lmao no. Because none of the the posts you quoted have a riot employee stating that they review every 7 day suspension before manually issuing it like i asked you to. All you did was quote a few posts which vaguely talk about how riot may monitor various degrees of punishments to make sure the tribunal is "doing the right thing"

That's absolutely not what i asked you to find, and your failure to provide what i requested only proves my point further.

There goes your "argument" then.