Originally Posted by Panzerfaust
'Some of the beefier AD carries are...' *list of some AD carries and some non-AD carries*
As you said, Cait and Trist can be hard to catch (so can Kog in that respect, more so even), but that doesn't make them 'beefy.'
Urgot is a really weird AD carry, because he really isn't an AD carry... he's an Urgot, nobody is quite like him.
Nidalee is almost always built as an AD bruiser, sometimes support, and on the rare occasion something else.
GP is a beef (though he varies on the scale from super beefy to fairly fragile melee depending on the build).
Ryze and Vladimir... as you said, mages. (Not AD carries.)
I specifically said that these weren't on his list. >.<
And he wasn't asking specifically for AD carry suggestions. He wanted ranged champs that don't melt in an instant. Ryze, Vlad, Nidalee, Urgot ALL fit that bill.
And I've found that people who like to attack from range and be "not squishy" like GP.
We can quibble over terminology all day, but I don't see how that helps new players pick champions they might like. I stand by my suggestions.