First report: 0/17 and entire team asking to have them reported. Minion Kills are a little high to be a feeder though. I likely would not have hit punish on.
Second Report: VERY surprised that got a pardon. Game 3 is clear punish for me.
Third Report: Again, how did this get pardoned? Just looking at Game 3 here is another easy punish.
Overall: I agree, those games were judged poorly.
And Trydan, before you start trying to troll and act like he's been 'banned unfairly' it helps to look at the reports first.