No one played Cho, Talon or Fiddles against him
Then there is this list.
These champs do well, the bolded & underlined are hard counters in lane that WILL shut him down when played properly:
Kass
Fiddles
Sion
Ahri
Alistar
Anivia
Annie
Blitz
Cho
Darius
Diana
Draven
Fizz
Galio
Jayce
Ken
Leblanc
Lulu
Malz
Noc
Panth
POPPY
Riven
Singed
Talon
TF
Veigar
Vik
Xin
Xerath
Raka
Vi
Elise
He's still beat by 33% of the champs in the game without being a total fool or understanding how to be patient.
Still OP because he is countered by 33% of the champ pool and two items depending on builld?
He is also hard countered by buying into MR. Getting 50% reduction is cutting his single damage skill in half (hence all his item purchases being cut as well).
AP Yi getting a nerf is telling me that this game company has succumb to fools who really have no counter argument to the fact that he is flat out beat hard by a large set of items and champs.
He is not hard to beat, and hasn't been hard to beat since beta.
If you were having a hard time, then explain why and I can tell you why you can do better.