in reply to phreak's post 400-some pages ago, I think the problem people have with this skin is that it doesn't feel different enough to the default TF to justfy the legendary status. people seem to approve more of the legendary skins that radically shift the character's theme.
olaf becomes a bro,
cho'gath becomes a gentleman,
tristana becomes a firefighter,
corki becomes a red baron,
nunu becomes nunu bot,
tryndamere becomes awesome demon-blade maniac,
fiddlesticks surprises us with a party (speculated legendary skin )
twisted fate goes from being a wild west card player magician to... just a card player magician.
add to the equation that the splash art doesn't have the same sense of occasion as the other legendaries. I was shocked to even learn that it was legendary, I'd have guessed it was like 520 RP.
I would like to point out though, that part of the problem is that the other legendary skins are generally just very impressive, so we have high expectations of them