OK, from the masses - would you approve of a Poppy ADC? Every time I pick her to run bot, I get a lot of groans or even D/C's because people think it is the dumbest thing because she is not ranged.
But hear me out.
I know she isn't ranged. because of that, you NEED a good support. She absolutely blows up enemy ADC's, and as long as you're careful early game, it gets ridiculous soon. The problem, of course, is CS. If you have a stunning/scary support with you though, they should be able to protect you. Once you get to 6, or you get sheen, you will be able to kill any other ADC in the game quite handily (even better if you're with a good blitz or voli).
I';m still trying it out, because I have gone 24-0 with Poppy bot, but also 5-5 or some other middling ratio. I see how people get pissed, but I also think a lot of it is unwarranted. I've converted a lot of people with my play, but I think with Poppy it really depends on how good your support is moreso than other champs.