Great job with this.

Well, i've been doing this for a few days and I must say im scared about the "voting rights deminished". I've voted punish on every case i've reviewed frankly because they are all more ridiculous than anyone i have ever played with, some going 0/26/1, and others spamming the N word throughout the entire game in multiple games. But if you need a large majority to punish, and much less to pardon, what if 20% of voters pardon for IP won't that wreck the system and make it so people like me who vote punish on those who deserve it unable to vote?

I'm already punishing trolls and violators of the summoner's code!, Beware because I'll have no mercy!!

Smells like bitter-sweet justice in the air...

So I just did my daily cases, all went smoothly and worked fine.
Although I didnt notice things like, end game time, total team scores and smaller things like this that can influence a case.
Maybe include information that tells us if anyone was teamed with others.
It would be unfair if a 4 queue jumped in with a pug and reported him for feeding and completely blamed him for it etc. Normally a 4 man party would be on some form of VOIP so they wouldnt even have to type in the chat log.
It may be a rare case, but it is still a scenario that can happen and having someone banned because 4 people literally bullied him/her would be the epitome of unfair judgement.

Some reports are funny though... I had one where people reported for negative attitude and intentional feeding aswell as AFK, yet the guy had a score of a carry, way more kills and assists then deaths, and his team won. He was a bit of a jerk sure, but IMO you can't punish him for that.

Wha? I would have pardoned the guy who was doing "verbal harassment" in that example...

I mean only ONE person on the entire team and enemy team reported him and his censored "verbal harassment" apparently consisted of a single curse word repeated, more like an exclamation of anger than directed hate.

Also, it has been said that merely cursing is unbannable: http://www.leagueoflegends.com/board...25#post4196825

Clearly, you should have pardoned the first case in question.

Yeah I pardoned a guy reported for intentionally feeding, afk, and verbal harrasment who was like 21/5/10 and who's team won.

I can't wait to use